Once upon a time, when doctors were like angels

E.R. RAMACHANDRAN writes: I was once treated by a doctor who was a ‘Gold Medalist’, a fact which was emblazoned after her name on the signboard outside her door.

She first treated me for malaria, which on its own or due to the doctor’s medicine soon turned to typhoid. After two weeks of various medicines, visiting gastro-enteritis and pneumonia on the way, both the doctor and the patient were nearing the edge of (her) knowledge bank and (my) existence.

The reputation of the gold medal was fast turning into silver and bronze.

It was around that time, somebody asked me to see Dr Mitra (name changed), a rare doctor in Delhi who most of the times never behaved like one. As I staggered into his clinic when my name was called, I found a youngish sort of man smoking in between large helpings of elaichi and diamond sugar bits.

Before my wife could finish my case history, he beckoned me to come out in the open and I followed him. Amidst the throng of patients waiting to see him, he asked me to gaze at the sunlight first and follow his fingers which kept moving sideways. He quickly went back to his room.

As we ran after him, he pronounced: “It’s jaundice. Throw away all the medicines. Bed rest for two weeks; only pathli dal and double-cooked kichdi. Next!”

We settled his bill and came out. How right he was!

Dr Mitra soon became our ‘family’ doctor and gradually, a friend. Once I went to him with a heavy cold and sour throat. He said, between puffs: “Salt water. Gargle thrice a day. No smoking till this stops!” I asked him, “How come you are smoking, doctor?” Quick came the repartee, “Who is having a problem? You or me?”

Whenever my wife and I would visit him, his first question would be, “Who is sick now?”

Once, when we were near his clinic, we felt like saying hello to him. We waited for our turn and when he threw his usual who-is-sick-now glance, we told him we had just walked in to say hello. He laughed heartily, “Looks like both of you are sick this time!”

When we invited him to come for dinner the following Saturday with his wife, he was surprised but agreed. He came in a suit with his wife, had a beer before dinner and gave a beautiful exposition the architecture of various Delhi heritage buildings! Otherwise laconic, he could talk of cricket for hours keeping the syringe in his hand much to the relief of the patient!

Once when we met him at a party, he was holding forth on the Emergency that had been clamped then, with a motley crowd gathered around him. When I asked him, “Long time, no see Dr Mitra,” he shouted back, “It’s fine. Keep it that way!”

While he was examining a patient, a persistent call from a big wig irked him no end: “Listen! I can’t drop my patients and come to see you. Just hop in to your car and come over. I will see you as soon as you are here. You won’t die! I will take the responsibility, if anything happens on the way.”

After a couple of years, I visited Dr Mitra with my colleague, who had two children and the elder of the two was mentally challenged. The family was going through tough times, unable to come to terms with the situation. Dr Mitra asked me to bring them home.

After spending some time with the family, he asked his wife to take care of the family while he sat with my friend and me.

He said: “Vijay, don’t feel bad if one of your children is mentally challenged. There is nothing you could have done about his birth. These are God’s ways of testing us. You can do one of the two things. Go and leave the elder child quietly somewhere in a forest and come back. Your problems due to the elder one will disappear forever. Your second son will grow normally and will do well. The other thing you can do is to accept the reality and bring them up. Dono, dilpe pathhar rakh kar karna hoga. May be one day the younger fellow will understand and he will protect his elder brother and will be a support to the entire family. You do your best and Bhagavan pe bharosa rakho. The choice is yours.”

The doctor refused any fee, and my friend was happy that he had sought Dr Mitra’s advice. The family went home a happier unit.

As I bid goodbye to the doctor, I thanked him profusely for the encouragement he had given. Dr Mitra just smiled and told me, “It’s nothing yaar. I am a doctor, na?”

As we passed a bedroom to go out, he showed his two children playing with a toy.

The elder one was mentally challenged.

About these ads

Tags: , , ,

12 Responses to “Once upon a time, when doctors were like angels”

  1. Bhaskar Chatterjee Says:

    Agree with ER. I had a similar experience when I used to work in Bangalore. Was suffering from huge breathing trouble because of large Parthenium concentration in and around Bangalore. Had to take daily injection and almost decided to quit my job and leave Bangalore.

    One of my colleague took me to one Dr. Ramu (name changed), a senior doctor in BLR. He gave me few medicine, stopped the injection, asked me to quit smoking till I live in Bangalore. Within few days, all my breathing trouble were gone, and I led a normal life there after. I still remember this incident that took place more than 2 decades back.

    When a doctor helps a patient from suffering, it creates a deep lasting psychological impact on patients. Those who have had that experience can only understand this.

  2. Mallige Says:

    Its all defensive medicine these days. Even the prescriptions of multi-drug cocktails are designed to overwhelm…and i mean not just the body. Gone are the days when Indian Doctors were known getting down to the root of the problem…treat and be done. Today there is a need to ‘impress’ patients with their high standards and beat around the curative bush in doing so. And twist things into yet another repeat consult. Also, despite the all stress on PR skills, the personal connections that yesteryears Doc’s forged are gone. Though we do try ;)

  3. captainjohann Says:

    This post brought tears in my eyes having a mentallyill dughter at home.Written with lot of feeling.Let this tribe of doctors grow.

  4. paciFIER Says:

    This means merit doesn’t matter – its the experience & skills. And people still take a dig at SC/ST doctors !

    I have a story to tell too. My ear was the problem. So I went to an ENT specialist, who had the most forward-looking surname. Our talk turned from my ear problem to the problems of the world. He cribbed how difficult it was for him to get a seat and how reservation is spoiling the chances of bright people like him.

    The pain didn’t reduce and so I had to go to his clinic the next day. He gave some ‘packs’ for the ear and assured me it will get better.

    After 2 more days the pain got worse. My neighbor suggested a doctor’s name. Reluctantly, I visited him and within 3 days I was 100% cured. Later I learnt that the doctor who cured me came from a socially-challenged community.

  5. Not A Witty Nick Says:

    paciFIER,
    The argument is that reservation breeds mediocrity, it’s not about SC/ST/OBC docs’ competence.

  6. Othla Boy Says:

    i am really starting to enjoy being a churumuri reader … i haven’t been here for long … the quality of posts and discusssion just keep bringing me back …

    @bhaskar: i second what you are saying about how treatment for suffering, especially if acute, leaves an indelible psychological mark on the patient. i think you can extend this to suffering in general. when someone redeems you from pain and suffering of any kind, you are just touched by that soul … you are filled with a sense of profound gratitude for that soul and life in general. this, in my mind, encourages and fills you with an urge to ‘pay it forward’.

    @captainjohann: i can feel your pain in your comment. we all have our own struggles. it’s amazing, isn’t it?, how simply reading this post has had such a cathartic effect on us … our pain is purged somewhat and we regain strength to continue fighting … dr. mitra is now one of my heroes … i’ll always remember him when i am being overwhelmed by life’s vagaries …

  7. Sir Vibhudi Aatmapudi Says:

    This is a brilliant piece written straight from the heart. I salute the writer.

  8. Sathya Says:

    The concept of family physicians is losing. Those doctors knew the family background and would treat the patients as human beings many times cajoling, joking and giving/prescribing medicines that would reduce the pain and suffering. Just a visit would do. Now with money and marketing coming into the fore it is rather disgusting sitting in the specialists chambers for a check up , sometimes they would not bother to hear even for a moment. Even in Mysore we had some good family physicians who would attend the patients even furing midnights. Now…

  9. sumakani Says:

    It was beginning of 80′s and I was working in a bank at a remote place in Bijapur Dist. Suddenly i had developed severe asthamatic problem though I had never had any history of asthamatic attacks. I thought it may be the climate of Bijapur dist which might not have suited me. I went to several doctors with my problem in and around the city but no results. Each doctor went on changing the prescription given by the earlier one telling that the medicnes prescribed by the predecessor will not work. At last I ended with a doctor who is known for not giving any injection and gives suggestions instead of medicines. When he saw me he gave a patient hearing and gave me some medicnes which costed me nothing compared to earlier prescriptions and asked me to come after 5days. Before I leave his clinic he casually asked me where I stay. I told the address. when I visited him on the given date he told me to stop taking medicines prescribed by him, though I told him that I have got relief and also advised me to change my house. I asked me why. He told that while going for morning walk he crossed my present house and further he saw that there was a huge fodder cutting machine was active and it was found to be working there for last few months. Then he came to the conclusion that the small dust like particles which were carried in the air is the culprit for my asthamatic attacks. I changed my house there afterwards I never had any such problem till my transfer from that place. Gone those days when your doctor used to think of patients (not about their pockets) even when they are on their personal chorus.

  10. Mayura Says:

    Great story. Hats off to ERR and Dr.Mitra(or whatever his name is). Another person who has a mentally retarded kid (is a grown up now) is Arun Shourie, it brings tears to your eyes to see how Shourie cares for his retarded son inspite of his busy lifestyle.

  11. Bevu Bella Says:

    ERR

    You have been flagging this story in a number of blogs.

  12. mia Says:

    Im very much touched with this story, If its possibl;e can i have the ph. no. & Add. of Dr. Mitra? Will be very thankfull …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 5,655 other followers

%d bloggers like this: