S.M. Krishna on the release of Dr Raj Kumar
Of all the many bushfires the S.M. Krishna regime had to douse, none is more gripping than the kidnapping of Dr Raj Kumar. Although, to its credit, the Congress government managed to secure the matinee idol’s safe release from the clutches of Veerappan after 108 days, the circumstances surrounding his freedom have effortlessly united politics, cinema, journalism, crime, big business, and the underworld at the hip.
At one level, the common belief was that Veerappan wouldn’t have just Raj Kumar go. Ergo: a democratically elected government had paid the sandalwood smuggler turned elephant poacher turned kidnapper-killer through his intermediary, R.R. Gopal, the editor of Nakkeeran. At another level, the speculation was over how much had been paid, and where the money had come from.
If the money had come from the government coffers, it was surely not likely to make that public. If it had been raised by the star’s family and/or the film world, no one was telling.
The first stone was cast by C. Dinakar, the former director general of police. In his 318-page tell-all book Veerappan’s Prize Catch: Rajkumar, Dinakar put the ransom figure at Rs 20 crore, and alleged that “taxpayer’s money” was used to pay off Veerappan. Then, Sangram Singh, a former assistant commissioner of police, deposed before the court that he had carried the money himself to Madras, from the residence of V.G. Siddhartha, Krishna’s son-in-law who owns Cafe Coffee Day.
Krishna and then home minister Mallikarjuna Kharge were present when he was sent off on the mission with the suitcases, claimed Singh, and went on to allege that “a white person wearing white safari with gold bracelet” too had been in their midst. Several months later, when H.T. Sangliana apprehended the fake stamp paper accused, Singh says he saw the same man at High Grounds police station. It was Abdul Karim Lala Telgi. In other words, the money may have come from less-than-honourable sources for less-than-honourable reasons.
Krishna has been characteristically silent on how the release was secured, which averted a major crisis for the government. With the former chief minister being sinecured to Maharashtra as governor, there was little need to answer the pesky questions. But with his return to active politics, the old ghosts have come back to haunt Krishna. Last week, Chetan of TV9 confronted him on the face-to-face interview programme Chakravyuha, and Krishna provided his version of the events, calling the allegations “ridiculous, preposterous, obnoxious”.
“It was my dharma, my responsibility, to get Dr Raj Kumar out. In that attempt, I succeeded.”
Videograb: courtesy TV9
Tags: C. Dinakar, Churumuri, Dr Raj Kumar, H.T. Sangliana, Mallikarjuna Kharge, Nakkeeran, R.R. Gopal, S.M. Krishna, Sangram Singh, Telgi, Veerappan
1 April 2008 at 5:29 pm
When in power SM Krishna kept the company, took counsel of some of the most unscrupulous, shady and criminal people. No wonder he resorted to illegal ways to address an issue that he should have in above board manner.
I am convinced Telgi’s ill gotten money was used by Krishna and his Home Minister Kharge who is “credited” with fleecing and extorting crores from Telgi.
Amusing, actually shocking, to see this gentleman is being seen as a saviour by party and being wooed Bangalore corporates !
1 April 2008 at 5:36 pm
The topic is interesting and significant for reasons mentioned and not mentioned in this post.
About the interview: both (the interviewer and the interviewee) seem appallingly inadequate and immature.
Look at the way the former governor, former chief minister, former Fulbright scholar’s body language and the language. If he gets so agitated and loses his reason while facing a question like this, I wonder if he had acted and behaved sanely when faced with the ticklish issues of administration. He tries to make Dinakar and Sangram Singh look insignificant by claiming that he has forgotten their names.
So, former chief minister somanahalli mallaiah krishna does not remember the name of the former Director-General of Police and his non-political enemy number 1 now! And he says no ransom was paid or at least ransom was not financed by the sale of fake stamp papers. What he forgets is the people would think that his claim ransom is as true as his claim on forgetting Dinakar’s name. He is defensive but given his experience he could have handled it better. He may get himself admitted to ‘Padmanabhanagar School’ for a crash course on the art of lying.
And about Chetan: the boy seems to have lost it at least in this bit of the interview. he should be better prepared, with better knowledge of recent history and a less arrogant style of asking questions with firmness and clarity of thought. He should do a lot better if does not switch to ‘English’ in a Kannada programme.
1 April 2008 at 7:52 pm
Dinakar had a axe to grind with the Karnataka Government. The result was the book he wrote about Raj’s kidnapping. In any case, was Raj not alerted by the intelligence agency not to go to his gajanur house, since they had reports saying Veerappan was planning to kidnap raj. If so, why did Raj ignore the advise by the intelligenece agency ?
1 April 2008 at 8:28 pm
“taxpayer’s money”
Stop grinning about it constantly.If something would have happened to Dr Rajkumar during that time,more than 10 times of that money would have bee destroyed due to riots.It was all avoided.
1 April 2008 at 9:08 pm
So in a way Telgi rescued Rajkumar…
If one is to believe in further rumours, the policemen who dealt with Veerappan buried his money (after all Veerappan didnt have too many avenues to spend the money after the Rajkumar kidnapping). And after the public forgot about the whole issue, they would have dug up the money for themselves. A bigger reward than the one given by the government.
So the money went from Telgi -> SMK’s minions -> Veerappan -> Underpaid (discluding bribes etc.) policemen.
So in a way money generated by magic by Telgi ends up in underpaid government officials pockets. Kind of poetic justice no?
1 April 2008 at 9:14 pm
S, If something had happened…..what else should have happened….ignoring the intelligence reports , the idol walked into the hands of the dantachora. There are many untold stories behind the kidnapping or whatever you may call it. .People of Karnataka are not rioteers. Right from the times of the Mahabharatha Krishna has been very diplomatically managing the affairs. People tend to forget their adversaries very conveniently. To cap it all, when he says that he made him the DG it sounds rather ridiculous. You may have to see many such dramas in future also
1 April 2008 at 10:05 pm
I agree with Subbu. They had to get Dr. Raj back somehow. Otherwise, there would have been blood bath in karnataka and tamilnadu. The loss of lives, loss to the IT companies, to the government would have been thousand times more than what was allegedly paid for the rescue. Raj lived few more years after that and it was worthwhile after all. Be happy that the episode ended peacefully.
1 April 2008 at 10:19 pm
Guys,
There was rioting when Raj died and crores worth of property was lost…does it mean that he should not have died at all….the point here is SMK should have been overboard when he dealt with this issue instead he set his henchmen DKShivakumar to collect loads of cash from business people, for the ransom money. Eventually, he ropes in Telgi to finance the ransom money. How good is that? So what happened to the money dikeshi collected is everybody’s guess.
1 April 2008 at 11:01 pm
Mayura,
Nothing is overboard in our politics. Especially when it comes to money. SMK got screwed in this case because of the unusual urgency of the case and Veerappan doing his side of the deal outside the normal framework. And normally the police take their cut and keep their mouths shut.
All Karnataka politics and lots of big business related work is kept functioning by suitcases of money.
If someone wants to be overboard within our system, then he can only operate at the lower levels or be a inconsequential fringe player like Dinakar.
1 April 2008 at 11:59 pm
I think there are too many untold truths in Rajkumar kidnap drama and thus it is difficult to find out who is the hero and who is the villain of the piece. There are a few points:
1) Despite his eccentricities I consider C Dinakar the bravest and honest officer with conviction. More than anything I appreciate him for his refusal to visit the bungalow in Sadashiv Nagar and cringe before the people there….
2) I think it is equally valid to ask why Rajkumar ignored the official advice and virtually walked into the trap of the ‘brigand’ by visiting Gajanur. How much of tax payer’s money can and should the government spend on one private individual’s security?
3) Those who say but for Rajkumar’s safe release there would have been bloodbath seem to be accepting such things as normal and inevitable. There would be no blood bath or destruction if the Government of the day allows the police to perform their duty.
4) It is just that all of us, including poor SMK are scared to speak truth when it comes to some holy cows
2 April 2008 at 3:09 pm
I think the answer to the question “will we ever know the COMPLETE truth about this episode” is a resounding NO and NEVER. I guess there is fair amount of data which is not available and is only with 8 - 10 people involved at that time.
2 April 2008 at 9:33 pm
I saw SMK’s interview on TV9. He comes across as pompous,arrogant,opinionated… unfit to be a chief minister or governor of the state…his fulbright scholarship notwithstanding. It is unfortunate he is again foisted on this poor state of ours
4 May 2008 at 7:51 pm
It is indeed most unfortunate to have politician like SMK whose illgotten money through his accomplices including his son in law, shamelessly continues to try to be our leader. May God only save us. Why telgi has not exposed him till now. Telgi will only make himself the biggest liar after having said he would expose all those whom he had bribed for his reliase.
8 May 2008 at 10:28 pm
SM Krishna is the best choice for the chief minister position….In the present political scenarion,nobody can be an Harishchandra ,but Krishna is 100 times better than Gowda ….