Comments on: New poll predicts Congress sweep in Bangalore

By: Nagaraj

Nagaraj — Wed, 21 May 2008 06:01:31 +0000

exit poll says that either BJP or Congress will get minimum majority.
but im challenging this time definetly it will be a coalition govrnment.
im 100% sure that this time congress and JDS together will form the government.so many exit polls are underestimating the JDS party but let them wait and see how crucial will be the JDS seats.they can’t under estimate the JDS because Kumaranna was a very popular CM.he is such a approachable CM i ever seen in the state.and he is having good leadership qualities than yediyurappa i dont think Yediyurappa is a quality leader.in Suvarna news channel Mr.Ramachandra Gowda was comparing Yediyurappa with Mr.Advani but yediyurappa is no where comparable with Mr.Advani.he is such a senior and eminent leader how can Mr.ramachandra gowda compare Yediyurappa with Mr.Advani.

By: vicharagalu

vicharagalu — Fri, 09 May 2008 12:28:26 +0000

There should be a clear ban on pre poll surveys. None of them can be accurate. and few hundreds or thousands cannot represent lakhs of voters. Many of such surveys have only yes or no. It can not be ideal

By: sid

sid — Thu, 08 May 2008 03:39:58 +0000

The best thing is the polls indicate a clear mandate compared to last time.
Any ways what matters are the poll results not thepre poll surveys

By: Odd-man-out

Odd-man-out — Thu, 08 May 2008 02:31:28 +0000

Every political party has their own poll agency, it seems.
Year after year their predictions have been falling flat on their face.
The recent case being the UP election results.
But, the poll prediction business and professions have been thriving well.
This was the reason why editor of one of the leading English national magazines decided to stop publishing any more poll predictions.
Why stop them at all? After all the poll bandwagons need something munch on and debate till the elections are over as the election commission has put the brake on all other types pre-poll entertainments.

By: Bhamy V Shenoy

Bhamy V Shenoy — Thu, 08 May 2008 00:15:51 +0000

Hope Churumuri will keep an account of all these polls and publish an article how they performed. That way at least we can hold them responsible to some extent.

By: P.R.Ramachander

P.R.Ramachander — Wed, 07 May 2008 23:55:15 +0000

I too as a statistician am not able to understand the results.But as a common man I am sure of one thing. Nothing is going to imrove, whatever may be the result. Ramachander

By: Shankar

Shankar — Wed, 07 May 2008 17:04:20 +0000

The poll says that people agreed that that 57% felt BJP-JDS governance was better than Congress-JDS governance and also that 53 % consider that JDS has betrayed BJP. If this is true one cannot understand how 42% prefer Congress against 29% for BJP.

This poll too fails to convince the public that the methodology adopted was reliable.

We all know that questionnaires can be clevery drafted and information mischievously collated to elicit misleading conclusions.

Unless the polling agency is completely trasparent about the selection of sample and the actual wordings used in the questionnaire, the poll result will be suspected.

It is not possible to accept that Bangalore voters are naive enough to forget the betrayal of BJP and it will have its impact on the public. What may favour of Congress is the constituency wise candidate preference and the muslim vote consolidation. Whether this will be decisive or not is not yet clear given the infighting in Congress and the unknown factor of BSP.

***

EC may mandate complete transparency of the survey and its conversion to the seat predictions if they have to be published.