POLLCAST: Is S.M. Krishna already chief minister?
S.M. Krishna may himself be very unsure of his position in the event of a Congress victory in the elections.
But the English news channels all seem to have unanimously crowned him the next chief minister of Karnataka. And they are acting as if it’s just a small matter of formality for the people to go and cast their vote as per their indication.
When CNN-IBN unveiled its pre-poll survey predicting a Congress win, Rajdeep Sardesai had S.M. Krishna interpreting the good news for the party.
When NDTV 24 x 7 did a special program on Bangalore last night, Sreenivasan Jain had S.M. Krishna as the link between the city’s past and future.
When Sagarika Ghose decided to look at Bangalore versus Karnataka last week, again S.M. Krishna offered his calm and considered views on the subject.
In NDTV’s promos for Saturday’s first phase of polling, Prannoy Roy pronounces that it’s a battle between S.M. Krishna and H.D. Deve Gowda.
And all the opinion polls have S.M. Krishna’s name up front in the list of aspirants.
So, it is S.M. Krishna, S.M. Krishna, S.M. Krishna.
Hand it to him, the Man from Maddur is nothing if not media savvy and he knows how to plonk himself in the media limelight.
When the Hogenakal row was blazing, he rushed to Delhi to meet the prime minister and was giving the first interviews as if he was already chief minister.
When Ramakrishna Hedge’s daughter went to file her nomination papers, he was helpfully in the camera frame.
Krishna sends bouquets to editors on their birthdays, he is always on call for interviews and quotes.
Why, he even earned the undying gratitude of scores of journalists when he gifted them expensive house sites under the “G” category.
So all that image-building and public relations is coming of use to him in this hour of need.
And to his good luck, none of his other senior colleagues Dharam Singh or Mallikarjuna Kharge or Siddaramaiah are endowed with such public relations skills.
Nor do they have the draw.
And truth to tell, of all the Congress characters on display, S.M. Krishna, where you like it or not, is probably the most telegenic of them all.
At least he can speak slow halting English, which is a prerequirement on our news channels.
And for another, he wears nice FabIndia™ kurtas which look better than the crumpled khadi jubbas and polyester shirts the rest of his tribe.
And, he has his hair in place, with a nice IT halo around it, all the time.
Above all, given the tragicomedy that Karnataka politics has been in recent years, at least the man represents something, even if some bits of it are massively tainted with corruption, nepotism and plain goondagiri.
S.M. Krishna probably will not grudge the media attention, probably he craves to be promoted as the face of the future although he is a full 76 years of age.
But if it is all so clear to the media that Krishna is the next CM, why isn’t it so clear to the Congress?
After he quit as Maharashtra’s governor and returned, the Congress kept him on the tenterhooks and didn’t give him a ticket.
And one well placed Congress source says the party has decided at the “highest level” that he will not get a chance to sit in the Vidhana Soudha again.
So what is the key takeaway from the media’s S.M. Krishna overkill?
That the Congress wants to use his suave, urbane, “image” and he is happy to allow them do so?
That there are two elections taking place, one for Bangalore and one for the rest of the state?
That one election is taking place in English, and the other in Kannada?
Be that as it may, can S.M. Krishna, after the 2004 verdict, still afford to be looked at as a chief minister of Bangalore if not the chief minister of electronic city?
Can he afford to be looked at as the media darling who fights from the cool comfort of air-conditioned studios, while his colleagues slug it out in the heat and dust?
Can he afford, really, to just woo the English masses, the so-called IT crowd?
And can the Congress afford to put all its urban eggs in one basket?
Also read: Can S.M. Krishna swing it for Congress?
Watch the video: S.M. Krishna on the release of Dr Raj Kumar
Tags: Churumuri, CNN-IBN, Dharam Singh, H.D. Deve Gowda, Karnataka Elections, Mallikarjuna Kharge, NDTV, Pronnoy Roy, Rajdeep Sardesai, Ramakrishna Hegde, S.M. Krishna, Sagarika Ghose, Siddaramaiah, Sreenivasan Jain
8 May 2008 at 5:52 pm
“He has his hair in place, with a nice IT halo around it, all the time.” Heheheh.
8 May 2008 at 6:38 pm
I think, given the likelihood that the BJP will sweep north karnataka, Congress’ strategy makes sense if they want a significant chunk of the 28 seats for Bangalore.
8 May 2008 at 6:40 pm
Some comments….
1. This ODEO .. video embedded object never seems to work…. fix it or forget it…
2. There is nothing wrong in being media Savy.
3. Why does the regional media not get the candidates together in the rural areas and why is it not highlighted in forums like this.. ( I said the same in a comment to a previous article). Get the miners … Iron ore.. and Sand miners (why did we forget the maraLu lorries and their strike) and the real estate agents and their political affiliates and put them to a similar
4. I watched a bit of the programme online… Srinivasan Jain saying that he comes to bengaloor 3 times a year and sees that a landmark has disappeared seemed a bit funny.
8 May 2008 at 6:43 pm
TVR Shenoy’s take
http://www.rediff.com/news/2008/apr/07flip.htm
The state enjoyed a Congress administration from 1999 to 2004. Any unbiased observer would have put S M Krishna in his list of the top five chief ministers in India. Chandrababu Naidu walked away with all the accolades in those years but if you ask me both S M Krishna and Jayalalithaa were every bit as good.
The proof came in 2004, when the Karnataka assembly elections were held alongside those to Parliament. The BJP swept the state in the Lok Sabha polls, winning 16 of Karnataka’s 28 seats.
Only Madhya Pradesh, electing 17 BJP candidates, gave better results to the party. Had the pro-BJP tide spilt over into the assembly polls, the party would have won 128 of the 224 assembly seats.
But the BJP did not do so; it won only 79 seats, well short of a majority. The Congress, which had won only seven Lok Sabha seats, did better in the assembly polls, winning 65. It would have won only 56 judging by the Parliament polls. Significantly, while the Congress forfeited its deposit in only seven assembly seats, the BJP did so in 42.
I think it would be fair to conclude from those results that, while they gave a distinct thumbs-down for Sonia Gandhi, Karnataka’s voters were willing to give Krishna their qualified approval. (It also speaks volumes for the political sophistication of the state that voters drew such clear distinctions between Parliament and the assembly even while they voted for both on the same day.)
Ordinarily, a political party would have encouraged the man who lost by such a narrow margin to stick it out and prepare the troops for the next round. But the clear message that Karnataka preferred S M Krishna to Sonia Gandhi was enough to ensure just the opposite in the topsy-turvy dynastic politics of the Congress.
True to form, Krishna was hastily bundled off to the Raj Bhavan in neighbouring Maharashtra by an ever-obliging prime minister.
S M Krishna is back in the fray today, but I am afraid his stock has not risen at 10, Janpath. When the latest imbroglio over the Kaveri began, Krishna rushed to Delhi to ask Dr Manmohan Singh to cool things over. It is no secret that he was, effectively, snubbed.
8 May 2008 at 6:56 pm
Srinivasan Jain… can some one please explain how he ended up with that oxymoron with the misfit suffix(to the first name) as his name?
8 May 2008 at 7:03 pm
Cool podcast, Churumuri.
Your suggestion that there might be “two elections taking place. . . one election is taking place in English, and the other in Kannada” speaks to the clout of Bangalore’s elite electorate rather than to Krishna’s image.
PS: NDTV nightly news rocks!
8 May 2008 at 7:14 pm
Not a witty,
Due to what we call ‘love marriage’?
8 May 2008 at 8:58 pm
Why Congress(I) did not allow S.M.Krishna to file his nomination any where in Karnataka ? NDTV do not know any thing about Elections in general and Karnataka in particular. Most of the news what we see in that channel is just wishful thinking of individuals. When the counting is over NDTV will start analysing to find the reasons as to where they did go wrong.
9 May 2008 at 12:01 am
>>”2. There is nothing wrong in being media Savy.”
That probably is not the point. There’s nothing wrong in Krishna being media savvy. It is just that like the author, I have also observed the Krishna-savviness of the English TV media recently. Obviously, the Sardesais and the Dagar Dutts and the Prannoy Roys get ‘decorated’ with awards by the Congress govt., and they feel obliged to do their bit for the Congress’ election campaign.
That Sagarika Ghosh’s interview with SMK and Siddu (in the same programme) is also revealing of the elitist rot and intellectual dishonesty that these channels have brought to the media. Watch it carefully.. first she conjures out of the blue, a “blore vs ktaka” dichotomy - tailor made to ensure that she can indulge in the self righteous “oh bangalore is going to dogs-see what they have done to blore post krishna-kannada chauvinism is on the rise” canard all she wants.
So, after conveniently setting up the viewer thus, she interviews SMK in his house and cannot help drooling over his ’sophistication’ and the visual seem to cry out — “ohh! see his house.. he even has a pooja room! the pooja room has tastefully carved teak panels!! and look! there is a pujari alladsing his gante in the pooja room!! I’m moved. eeks! he eats idli vade with a spoon!! What a man! Blessed are we that we will have him at the helm after these elections”…
Then she moves to Siddu, who much to her discomfiture also has a pooja room in his house! And the bugger even speaks English!! God.. and then the idiot has a Mona Lisa (not a Maramma) hanging in his drawing room.. oh we’re so owned.. boo hoo.. what shall I do? Gotcha! look.. he’s eating masale dose with his bare hands! sheesh! how parochial and chauvinistic is that?!.. I am sure if I asked him.. “Shree Sidarumayaji.. do you think that Kannadigas should get priority in Karnataka”.. to which Sidarumaya answers at length that he is indeed for it.
Gotcha!!.. Back to the studio.. snip my question out.. add my commentry in.. squeeze in Sidarumayaji’s answer and lo and behold! We have the viewer totally convinced that all but SMK are parochial chauvinists.. and the contrast we have so very convincingly etched between the american gowda and the kuruba demonstrates the blore-ktaka divide..
“I told you it existed.. I told you. See if you believe you can take your viewers for a ride, you’ll find something as you go along. You must believe in yourself…you should be a go-getter. whew!” sagarikaji was heard telling a certain deepa balakrishna - the stammering kongati who these days seems to be perfecting her art of KKK-baiting (remember when the sidilu badidante mira mira minchutta iruva “superstar” speaks in Kannada, he is “speaking in a language the Kannadigas understand”
WTF! Journalism seems to be the first refuge of scoundrels.
9 May 2008 at 12:01 am
yay!! churumuri in the news
http://www.ndtv.com/convergence/ndtv/videopod/default.aspx?id=28530
9 May 2008 at 12:05 am
ayya chef-in-chief-u. why cant you podcast like you spoke in that interview?
i am going to keep nagging you till you stop speaking like you are writing.
9 May 2008 at 2:33 am
Who is that rascal who own churumuri, such a shame to all Bangaloreans because of this blog. Details…
9 May 2008 at 8:41 am
a person who cant appear in public without his WIG does not deserve to be even a minister.Everything about him is fake.He and his cronies looted crored of rupees through land deals and one of his favorite chelas made money while making payment to Veerapan,Collected 30 crores from film stars, quarry owners , builders and other industrialists and in the absence of proper checks and balances in the system made a cool 20 crores as only 10 cores was paid to the brigand.
9 May 2008 at 9:12 am
What ever the English News Media may harp or churn out. SM Krishna will not be the next CM period.
9 May 2008 at 11:20 am
Well Said Sisya,,
9 May 2008 at 4:14 pm
If the Congress gets around 100 seats followed by BJP or vice versa, both the parties may indulge and also succeed in splitting the JDS,by making a tantalising offer of plump ministerial posts and heads of the various government Boards and corporations, take support of independents and form a government with outside support of the splinter group. This time they may not allow Dodda Gowdru become a ‘King Maker’ again.
10 May 2008 at 10:38 am
Its high time we matured to face reality in its face. And there’s no prize for believing this - the face of the English media (at least in our immitatist journalist clan in India) is surely well bleached of truth. The white-is-true feeling of this english media needs to be faced with a black wall of neglect and ignorance.
The diverse natured audience in our system needs to ignore the Indian english media which is blindly imitating the ways of BBC and CNN to become the NDTV and IBNs around us, while completely forgetting that they’re dealing with a multitude of cultures and their corresponding expectations, unlike in places that they’re imitating.
Neglect the “verdict” these media are giving and vote by yourself! The real “Krishna” is in all of us, and we need to wake up to this truth. Sitting & expecting an idli-eating SMK or a masale-dose eating SS with all their wall-posters will come and catch us from falling into this pit will be stupidity. Vote for who you KNOW is good, and lets not vote so that a particular character becomes this-M, that-M, or CM.
BTW, very well articulated by Sisya!
10 May 2008 at 10:45 am
ssss
11 May 2008 at 4:00 am
Why does Master Kishan from Maddur do everything commanded by the nitwits in Dilli? I wonder how he conveys his consent to them without nodding and risking the wig to slip off.
12 May 2008 at 12:50 am
I have a bad problem with lisping. I find myself saying, “Krishna already thief minister.” Is Dr. Ramanarao still around?