‘Indian media is obsessed with obtuse authors’

CHETAN KRISHNASWAMY writes from Bangalore: On the many occasions we have swigged beer in Bangalore’s seedy bars, adwoman turned author Anita Nair has ensnared me with her intellectual vigour and literary range.

At other times, she has puzzled me with her flippant—and alarmingly consistent—appearances on Bangalore’s airy Page 3 circuit. It is apparent that Anita loves to gambol with the “wolves and lambs” at these events, although sometimes she vehemently, and playfully, denies it.

Her latest novel, the 329-page Lessons in Forgetting, brings out both these contrasting facets of the writer’s personality. “This is probably the most intense and complex novel that I have ever written,” says Anita, caressing the dancing ringlets framing her face.

The narrative style of Lessons in Forgetting is fast paced but nuanced in a sophisticated sort of way. The primary characters Meera and Krishnamurthy aka Jak, two very different individuals from two diverse worlds, find themselves staring into a bottomless abyss.

Afflicted by a deep crisis, the two individuals come together to exorcise the demons within.

The growing eye of a raging cyclone turns into a masterly metaphor, an unlikely cerebral backdrop for Anita’s story to take shape: “The only certainty about a cyclone or despair is the uncertainty it triggers. And as with despair, the cyclogenesis of a tropical storm is seldom announced. What is certain is the resultant turbulence.”

Lessons in Forgetting is Anita’s fourth novel, after a collection of short stories, a book of poetry, four children’s books and an anthology of essays on Kerala. Her latest novel will be available in bookstores across the country from Feb 1.

Excerpts from an interview she gave churumuri.com:

***

Chetan Krishnaswamy: Lessons in Forgetting is a rather unconventional name for a work of fiction. How did it come about?

Anita Nair: Actually, I had a different working title, but that began to sound too poetic; it lacked the resonance. I wasn’t too happy with it. One fine morning, this title appeared in a flash. No rhyme or reason. Everytime I am swimming, I actually forget to breathe, and I keep joking that I should take lessons on how not to forget breathing while I swim. Probably, that was the genesis of the title. The final endorsement came from my 18-year old son, whose instinct I have trusted for years.

My publishers leapt at it and found it to be apt as well. Moreover, the title and the plot synchronized well.  Both the characters in my novel  Meera and Jak have had devastating experiences in life. They need to get past it all and move on. They are constantly wrestling with their memories. Even the minor characters need to put behind their past lives and surge ahead. The title seemed perfect.

At a basic level the story is seemingly straightforward, but beneath you realise that it is a highly textured, complex narrative.  I thought that using the scientific genesis of a cyclone as a metaphor to illustrate the evolving turbulence in the lives of your two protagonists was hugely creative.

Anita Nair: I was sitting with my friend Sudha Pillai one afternoon, and she told me that she was working on a cyclone film for National Geographic. That triggered of my quest to understand how cyclones are created and I incorporated my research with a literary touch in the story.

I began writing Lessons in Forgetting in October 2006. The idea was to write a light, feel-good novel. I even began the story with a typical Page 3 party, but eventually decided that I was not up to it. How could I work on some rubbish for three years? I started giving it dimensions, a fresh texture, and in due course found myself working on this rather complex narrative.A lot of the situations, I had to build in my mind, since they were not borne out of my experiences: The husband deserting the wife, raising a teenage daughter, the predicament of a woman not knowing how to cook, etc. I also brought in Greek mythology and constantly compared Meera to the Queen of the Universe, Hera. Indian gods and goddess are not given to perfidies but the Greek gods are more human, and I love those stories.

On the one hand, this novel comes with a strong feminist stamp to it. The women are very strong and independent minded. You bring up female foeticide. But then you also indulge in shockingly old fashioned stereotypes like how marriage becomes essential for a woman, how it gives a sense of security to the woman, how a divorcee or a widow does not find favour in a social gathering, etc. Why this contradiction?

Anita Nair: Being a bold feminist is aspirational and the sterotypes that you refer is reality of the day. I am a woman writer not a feminist. My plot is unintentional on most occasions. I write for the sheer joy of writing, not to make a statement. I don’t write to jolt the system.  I am not an activist.

Aren’t you abdicating your responsibility as a writer in the process?

Anita Nair:  I have often been criticized for being reticent. I believe that what I write should speak for itself.  I am against authors wearing their ideology on their sleeve. Authors themselves are so fickle. Their causes keep changing in keeping with their current obsession. I speak through my books and I don’t want to publicly voice my sentiments or thoughts.

You seem to be taking potshots at the preening Page 3 crowd in your book, something that you are an integral part of. That’s hypocrisy now?

Anita Nair: I haven’t exaggerated the Page 3 culture one bit in my book. It is a world where everybody feeds off each other. That’s exactly how it is. Since I am a part of it all, I may be deprecating myself through this novel. At these parties, there is always somebody hitting on you all the time. Now I am going to be in serious trouble. Nobody is going to invite me ever (Smiling) . Frankly, to this day, I don’t know why I am invited.

Like you mention in your book, the PR guys who orchestrate these events think that you are sexy, photogenic, probably that’s why.

Anita Nair: What rubbish! No seriously. I think they invite me because I stimulate the atmosphere with my conversation. I have also been living in this city for a long time and know a lot of people. I probably also find a place on the invitee list because of my food writing. Sometimes they want a few token intellectuals to add credibility to the event . Anyway I am not trying to take the high moral ground and belittle anybody. It is just a social observation.

How many guys have hit on you so far?

Anita Nair:  Thankfully I attend these parties with my husband. I can play beautifully obtuse when somebody propositions me. I act like a bimbette.  I remember this guy coming up to me and casually asking whether my husband was still around. He meant whether I was still married. I stupidly looked around and said yes, he’s somewhere around. For the discerning few, a lot of Bangalore’s page 3 characters are visible in my book.

Tell me, do you gasp for breath, get turned on, when you write those frenzied love-making scenes in your books, are you self-conscious at all about this aspect of your writing?

Anita Nair: Actually, when I write the many sexual interludes in my books, I write with a smile.  I cease to exist as a person. I write the scene in my head. Later, when I read them I am almost amused at my vivid imagination.

Sometimes I feel you are writing these graphic details merely to sensationalise or titillate to sell your books. Why would  anybody be interested in how a woman’s armpits smell? You do make that description in your novel, right?

Anita Nair:  No way! Each of these sexual sequences are integral to my story. A certain amount of self-editing happens almost automatically. I know when to stop and not go overboard. But I do have a lot of people coming up to me and perversely dwelling over these facets in my books.

In the early days as a writer, people would come upfront and make a pass at me without even thinking twice. They assume that because you write about sex you are probably sleeping around. They try hard to find out how many men I have slept with. I just play dumb. In real life, if I did everything I write, I would be leading a very busy life.

Do you think you have got your due as a writer?

Anita Nair: The simple answer is, No. The literary establishment has not recognised my efforts. Sometimes, it results in huge self doubts about my abilities. I hide behind this placid façade but it’s not easy. The measures that the media uses to judge creative works  is also completely inconsistent.

It is obsessed with writers like Amitav Ghosh, Amit Chaudhuri, Pankaj Mishra.

It almost seems that a work has more gravitas if it’s obtuse. But the moment a book becomes accessible, it seems to lose value. It’s probably because I haven’t shown the workings that go behind writing a book, the amount of research that goes in, etc. But I am happy when I get a letter from a mother from some remote part of the world telling me that her relationship with her daughter is much better after she read one of my books. These small changes,  that my books bring about in people’s lives are significant for me.

How important is it for a writer to be rooted in the vernacular, in the native milieu. In that sense you pander to the urban elite, don’t you?

Anita Nair: It is very important for a writer to relate to his roots and have grounding in a regional language. I read Malyalam quite extensively. I speak it very well and follow all the literary trends in Kerala. I will be translating a famous Malyalam novel very soon. I will also commence writing a historical novel on medieval Kerala shortly, a world nobody knows about and wrongly depicted in movies.

About these ads

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

20 Responses to “‘Indian media is obsessed with obtuse authors’”

  1. Vishala Manassu Says:

    “caressing the dancing ringlets framing her face.”
    speechless!!

    softporn + page3 = bestseller!!

  2. Yella OK Says:

    “ensnared me with her intellectual vigour and literary range.”

    “I think they invite me because I stimulate the atmosphere with my conversation”

    Surely, this interview was conducted after swigging beer at one of those seedy places!!!!!!

  3. nilesh Says:

    Just curious,

    Do you speak kannada

  4. lol Says:

    Did she actually say “obtuse”? From the context, I gather she meant “obscure.” For a writer, she doesn’t seem to choose her words very carefully.

  5. gaby Says:

    This woman of ‘literary range’ says the INDIAN gods are not given to perfidies. Who on earth are Indian gods- Kautilya, Indira Gandhi and Devegowda – and not perfidous?
    If the perspicacious writer actually meant Hindu Gods then what does she call the the seduction of Ahalya, the rape of Vrunda, the deceiving of Bali etc !!!

  6. S K Kumar Says:

    Ms Anita Nair’s sartorial taste is atrocious. However, these publicity mongering people know how to be in the limelight. These party animals are having a gala time; for at least three English newspapers in Bangalore are vying with one another to help these worthies peer out of the pages.

  7. Pulikeshi the Last Says:

    Excellent observation, LOL.

  8. tsubba Says:

    On the one hand, this novel comes with a strong feminist stamp to it. The women are very strong and independent minded. You bring up female foeticide. But then you also indulge in shockingly old fashioned stereotypes like how marriage becomes essential for a woman, how it gives a sense of security to the woman, how a divorcee or a widow does not find favour in a social gathering, etc. Why this contradiction?

    i hope this question is not a reflection of your own personal thinking and understanding of the issue. i hope you only asked this question to comply with form, just to sound correct, just to show you know about what the theory of feminism is.

    some articles on vaidehi.

    http://www.hinduonnet.com/fr/2007/02/16/stories/2007021601910400.htm

    http://www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/thscrip/print.pl?file=2010010151050400.htm&date=2010/01/01/&prd=fr&

  9. Indian Homemaker Says:

    “I am against authors wearing their ideology on their sleeve. Authors themselves are so fickle. Their causes keep changing in keeping with their current obsession. I speak through my books and I don’t want to publicly voice my sentiments or thoughts.”
    She wants to speak through her books, but she doesn’t want to publicly voice her thoughts?
    She is against authors wearing their ideology on their sleeves? Should the authors write about somebody else’s ideology?
    She doesn’t sound like an author I would ever like to read.

  10. Madhu Rao Says:

    Might just be me, but the piece is a treatise in “softball questionnaire”. The post begins with a paragraphs that professes “…ensnared me with her intellectual vigour and literary range..” and keeps on with the playful, flirtatious tone ; it does mention page-3 — but that’s like mentioning being a ‘stickler for detail’ as a personal flaw, especially considering her reader base. The interview continues the leitmotif with the ‘sexy, photogenic’ author contradicting herself and Chetan ignoring it. I would have rather-ed someone who had not ‘..swigged beers in Bangalore’s seedy bars (with the author)…’ do the interview.

    Unfortunately, this piece did not do justice to the readers or the author and was, among other things soft, a soft publicity. A semi page-3 piece..

  11. Faldo Says:

    @Madhu, the impression I got was very similar to how you put it …stickler for detail as a flaw. Exactly! While it was nice to know about this upcoming author, the churumuri in this case was too sweet and lacked spice.

  12. Doddi Buddi Says:

    A fitting headline to this interview should be:

    Would you be found swigging beer in a seedy bar with this opaque woman?

    Me DB, no I wouldn’t.

    Chetan K,

    Give us some names of these seedy bars, please. Thanks.

  13. mysore peshva Says:

    utterly pretentious.

  14. Prashant Krishnamurthy Says:

    For all her “intellectual vigor and literary range”, Ms Nair can’t seem to rise above the oldest crib in the business, that nobody takes note of her efforts because they are all looking at the others in the ring.

    How original!

    Hearing Ms Nair, one almost instinctively begins to salute the titanic achievements of R.K. Narayan. Sitting in “small-town” Mysore in the early part of the 20th century, how did the man decide to take on his family, friends and decide to make a career in words, English words at that, and achieve great success without the drum-beaters of the page 3 media reporting every party, book release and dance recital he went to?

    Moral of the story: those who live by the t-and-a supplements of The Times of India and want to be taken seriously shall be condemned to long, saccharine interviews with drinking mates in “seedy bars”.

  15. Simple Says:

    Only plain escapist writers hide underneath the knickers of excuse: “I am not an activist, I write for the sheer joy of writing.”

    Why sit in judgement about other authors who feel passionately about taking up a cause? What is wrong if this kind of activism reflects in their writing?

    There is no harm. In fact, it inspires millions of others to take up the cause with renewed vigour.

    Chetan Bhagat is derided by the ‘writers’ industry’ for lack of intellectual depth, simplistic plotlines and mediocre prose.

    Like Anita, Chetan also ‘speaks’ through his writings. But he dares take a stance. No wonder, today he is the most successful Indian English Author. Ever.

    Anita takes snide potshots at the other well known authors in India. For all her alleged intellectual abilities, Anita is not above the oldest, most instinctive emotion in the world, which afflicts even six year old children : It’s called jealousy.

  16. Anshuman Patel Says:

    Some kinda Airy fairy this one is or on second thoughts (looking at the pic) hairy fairy..

    “Indian gods and goddess are not given to perfidies but the Greek gods are more human, and I love those stories.” Reading this Ta da I figured out this one is truly ‘Anita in Wonderland’!

  17. Dheerendragopal Says:

    Aunty Picture hakkid thakshna ..comment mele comment .
    Ashwath avara Postge obbanu comment hakkakke gathiyilla

  18. Rakesh Says:

    It seems this post came from Kerala, or a person from Kerala was on the phone.

    I may be wrong, but this blog posted some “quoted” items in the recent past that said men in Kerala are only interested in looking at boobs.

    Here, first, the interviewer on the phone talks about her writing as in any other online or print magazine — and the pervert jumps straight into a conversation that reeks of SEX.

    I thought at least this blog was not under the influence. You think you can fool everybody?

  19. Chunky Boy Says:

    Let’s see, I am now curious about this book, what with sex and the smell of a women’s armpits!

    I hope there is enough of it to make the buy worth it, although I did save some money online at http://www.indiaplaza.in/lessons-in-forgetting-anita-nair/books/9788172239046.htm

  20. katrina Says:

    For all her “intellectual vigor and literary range”, Ms Nair can’t seem to rise above the oldest crib in the business, that nobody takes note of her efforts because they are all looking at the others in the ring.

    How original!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 7,497 other followers

%d bloggers like this: