MANISHA MODHA-PATEL writes from Ahmedabad: It was in the year 1980 that I first met her.
I was 12 years old.
Our family had just moved from Bombay to Mysore. Besides the lovely weather, the new place offered new friends, a new house, and a new school with new classmates and new teachers.
Moving to a new place always has its moments, apart from the difficulties of finding your way and melding in. The language barrier makes it even more so.
In namma Mysooru, Kannada posed countless troubles to me: from the emotional trauma of not being able to converse with many of my classmates to the physical pain of manoeuvering the finger to write it.
Enter Miss Ponnamma George.
My class-teacher at Nirmala School who introduced me to the nuances of the new language; my writing coach who taught me the way to hold the pencil to etch its letters on paper; the language guide who taught me how to make sense of the what I heard and how to start speaking it myself.
The fact that my parents, who were as new to the City as I, were of little or no help in managing this new language, compelled me to put in extra time in learning it all on my own.
It meant the agony of an extra one hour of class every day after school. The charge? Ten rupees—yes, Rs 10—per month!
It meant the agony of watching all your classmates happily go home and play, while you sat at the desk learning the alphabet by rote, writing the same new words and new sentences countless number of times.
Homework and more homework.
If, over time, Kannada became something I could handle, it was entirely because or Miss Ponnamma.
The ever-smiling lady had the patience and sensitivity to make the extra class delightful. She taught to me to converse in Kannada and didn’t laugh when I did and tripped. Over time, Kannada seemed easier and my equation with her grew stronger.
It was Miss Ponnamma who explained to me that kencha or kenchi was not a foul-word but an adjective meaning fair, although it sounded like one when the K-word was yelled at us while we were having lunch. It was Miss Ponnamma who explained who a halli guggu or a goobe or an emmay was.
It was Miss Ponnamma who revealed to me that besi bele hulli anna and puliyogere were not words belonging to some botanical species but rice dishes; that mosuru anna was curd- rice and not to be pronounced as Mysore anna. That illa kan’e and illa kanó were equivalent to “No, yaar” in English.
It wasn’t quite high literature, but it was useful for a young girl finding her feet.
What endeared me to Miss Ponnamma was her infinite patience with me. It was reassuring to hear her say “paravagilla” (ït’s OK) whenever I made a mistake, and it was often enough, believe me.
When she announced me to be the monitor of the class, I was shocked but realised that Miss Ponnamma did like me a wee bit more. Was I now one among us (nammavaru?), not an “outsider” (bere-avaru)? If it wasn’t for this little action by Miss Ponnamma, I would never have been the person I was in school!
Doing all the little tasks for her, getting her bag from the teachers’ room to those charts we prepared for the school exhibitions, to just being around her whenever she needed me. School was definitely the place to be in. And once a student is made monitor, life becomes somehow easier. (Ask all monitors.)
I remember her inviting me and a classmate Preeti Attavar to her marriaju when we were in our seventh standard. This made me feel even more special. The whole class collected money to buy a gift (including a purple lipstick from Mohan Bhandar!), and Preeti and I went to Saint Bartholomew Church to hand them over.
I knew that my presence would mean a lot to her. It certainly did to me. A glimpse of a Christian wedding and my first one at that. She looked lovely in a white saree. And I had thought all Christian brides wore those lovely gowns that made them look like a fairy. She indeed was one for me!
Life, was easy in 7th standard, courtesy Miss Ponamma, and the subsequent years were even better. After going to the high school, meeting her sometime, just made my day.
A chance conversation with another classmate two years ago revealed she was still teaching in the same school after 30 years and was in charge of the school alumni. I made a phone call and told her that I was her student and would she remember me?
“This is Manisha,” I said.
“Manisha Modha?” came the prompt response from the other end of the line. “What is Preeti doing? They don’t make students like you any more.”
To which I just have to say, this Teacher’s Day: “They don’t make teachers like you any more, Miss Ponnamma!”
Today, when I want my school-going children to meet at least one Miss Ponamma in life, so that they have good memories of school in later years, a small voice in me tells me, partly out of nostalgia, partly out of experience, “Miss Ponnamma, nimma taraha teachers innu mundhe baralla.”
Thank you, m’am.
***
Which teacher/s do you most remember most from which school? Name them—and ‘fame’ them.
***
Also read: Once upon a time, shortly after the lunch break
Once upon a time, when the gari didn’t put mari
Once upon a time, in Ramakrishna Vidyashala
Once upon a time, in Maharani’s college. (Yes!)
From Guruswamypalya, a lesson for all shishyas
Tags: Churumuri, Manisha Modha, Nirmala School, Ponnamma George, Preeti Attavar, Sans Serif
4 September 2010 at 12:43 pm
Very nicely written article. Thanks for sharing :)
4 September 2010 at 2:28 pm
To a mind bored and frustrated with corruption, crime and nonsense all around, such articles are a great solace, inspiration and rejuvenation. Thanks Manishaji. May the breed of persons like Ponnamma and Manisha grow. ಓದಿ ಬಹಳ ಸಂತೋಷ ಆಯಿತು. ಪೊನ್ನಮ್ಮ ಅವರಿಗೆ ವಿಶೇಷ ಧನ್ಯವಾದಗಳು. ನಿಮ್ಮ ತರಹ ಶಿಕ್ಷಕರೂ ಮತ್ತು ವಿದ್ಯಾರ್ಥಿಗಳು ಚಿರಾಯುವಾಗಿರಿ.
4 September 2010 at 2:52 pm
Amazing article !
4 September 2010 at 2:54 pm
Good one. Thank you.
4 September 2010 at 7:29 pm
What a heartening article! Thanks, Manisha.
Beloved Miss Ponnamma was my class teacher in 6th standard “A,” 1985-86. She was my favorite teacher at Nirmala, and I like to believe I was among her best pupils!
I do not remember her giving “cuts” on the knuckles to anybody. I do not remember her scolding any student. I do not remember her even raising her voice, ever. Yet, she was effective in her instructions. My best friend SD and I, both on the front bench, frequently violated her “no talking!” instruction, and indulged in all manner of pranks that we still talk about. Miss Ponnamma’s admonishment was invariably to repeat her instruction, any number of times. Was her method effective? You bet. She exuded a patient, benevolent nobility that could shame us into listening to her! — she commanded respect through affection.
When a teacher walked in, students were to stand up and say in unison, “Good morning, Miss!” Over time, that greeting would begin to sound less and less crisp, and more and more like a stuck record player. Miss Ponnamma’s amusement would show in a beatific smile.
I do not remember her for anything idiosyncratic — neither quirks of speech nor peculiarity of behavior. I remember that she cared, whether it was for my or HSR’s drawing/sketching or singing skills, or for SD’s poem-reciting skill, or for SM’s batting skill.
Miss Ponnamma was truly like a sadhu, exuding inspiration, bliss and affection.
I remember her, also, for a school trip to Ooty, when she had sat next to me in the bus. Ordinarily, I loved to watch the scenery moving outside, but I had shut the tinted window to focus on my conversation with Miss Ponnamma! She was an excellent conversationalist, partly because she was a respectful listener — even with a crazy 11-year-old. It’s amazing, but I vividly remember what we talked about — my sister’s winning the zonal-level chess and swimming tournaments; a bright new student, ST, who had just left Nirmala for a school in Madras; the speed limit in Tamil Nadu; whether it was a TELCO bus or Ashok Leyland…
At the Hotel Woodlands in Ooty, where we had lunch, Miss Ponnamma (among others) sat at my table. It was probably my first time at a restaurant, ever — I was 11 years old, and eating out had never been a tradition at home. As we waited for the food to come, I saw a man who had dined on the neighboring table had got up and was walking away, leaving a few coins in a wooden basket on the table. Assuming he had forgotten to take his money, I leaped out of my chair, grabbed the coins, and ran after him, catching up at the door and handing him the money. The man smiled and said the coins were a “tip,” and I should put them back on the table! So I did. Miss Ponnamma, who saw it all, couldn’t help laugh. She complimented me for “observing so much.” :)
When my wife and I found ourselves in Ooty (for our honeymoon) some 20 years later, we picked the Woodlands. It seemed a bit rundown by then, but hey, it was familiar!
4 September 2010 at 9:47 pm
It was a pleasure reading the article – thank you for sharing.
Varghese George (Miss Ponnamma’s brother from California)
4 September 2010 at 11:15 pm
Enjoyed the article. Very nice..
5 September 2010 at 10:15 am
Nice article.. But
>> “equivalent to “No, yaar” in English.”
English ???
5 September 2010 at 12:30 pm
I really felt proud reading this article about my beloved sister. She has been always like this from her childhood,not only as a teacher but also at home. the best child in the family. simple, honest, hardworking, and eversmiling, a sadhu as one of you put it.
It brought me memories back when we all used to live in one house. I always remember your values and contributions to me as a big sister.
All the great men and women in this world are in their status today because of a ‘teacher’ once upon a time. But most people tend to forget this amidst their busy lives
It is a pity that teachers are not recognised or categorised as the so called popular professions like doctors and engineers and yet these doctors and engineers were produced by these humble teachers.
I sincerely thank each one of you for your honest comments about my sister. Really it was a pleasure reading the article. You go Girl !
Mariamma George Raju; Education Specialist ; South Africa ; (Ponnamma’s younger sister) former Nirmala Convent student.
5 September 2010 at 11:17 pm
Thanks Manisha.
As Kahlil Gibran said..’No man can reveal to you aught but that which already lies half asleep in the dawning of your knowledge.’
You were ready and you were lucky Ms. Ponnamma was there. Both of you indeed embody the idea of India.
6 September 2010 at 9:44 am
Mariamma, kindly convey my best wishes to your sister and thanks from a Kannadiga.
6 September 2010 at 2:11 pm
Hi Manisha
Now I know how you were able to use those Kannada words during “SPACE” days.
Good one…
6 September 2010 at 9:40 pm
A touching article.. Hope all children get more teachers like Ponnamma..
7 September 2010 at 4:29 pm
wow! thanks for the article. I recall going and visiting her when she delivered a baby. We cycled our way to her home – Past TB hospital [ sanitorium] –
when we reached her home , we realised we had not carried any gifts / sweets – so we bought few biscuits from a local store.
she accepted it with a gentle Smile.
8 September 2010 at 11:33 am
Well done, Manisha. Teachers are born not made by qualification, influence and corruption but, by their knowledge, perseverance, dedication and affection towrds his/her students.They go on teaching day in day out, but if we learn a little and carry forward, preserve and impart to others, it is great respect to a teacher on Teacher’s day. Let present age trachers get lession from this.
9 September 2010 at 10:30 am
This was 30 years ago, right? You can not see such a milieu nowadays. No one is bothered to learn Kannada, and Kannada is no longer the language of communication in Bangalore or Mysore.
***
I just mean that you could survive in these cities even without learning Kannada.
9 September 2010 at 2:36 pm
Hats off to both Mrs. Ponnamma and Ms. Manisha. You both embody the true spirit of India..
“Bharata Jananiya Tanujaathe
Jaya He Karnataka Maathe”
- Hail Karnataka, the daughter of Mother India
9 September 2010 at 4:29 pm
Thumba Chennagide!
Good One!
9 September 2010 at 9:21 pm
nice to see respect for other languages. it is not common among all indians!
10 September 2010 at 2:08 pm
Respect and Salute to all our teachers, What ever we are today, they definitely had a great part to play.
May the tribe of teachers like Ms. Ponnamma increase and flourish all over India.
11 September 2010 at 4:04 pm
Hi Manisha,
On this 11th day of Sept.2010, let me first of all wish you a very happy Ganesh Chathurthi. Also to all those who responded to Manisha’s article remembering me on ‘Teachers’Day of 5th Sept. 2010. There are students of mine who after leaving the 7th std; the very next year when they meet me they keep telling “Miss, we miss you a lot”. “Miss we miss you teaching Social science”. There are mothers who meet me and say, Miss if at all my daughter knows something in Maths, its ’cause of you. You have given the right foundation, etc; etc. When I hear these, I never felt anything ’cause this was common every year.ut Manisha, after reading your article,and its responses, I feel that I am elevated to the pinacle.omething Unique- say after 30 long years, remembering all that has happened during your school days in 1980′s. Some years ago, one old student created question in the Orkut -Who is your best teacher in the Middle school? I was astonished to see that among the 4 0ptions, majority of the votes were for me. sometimes I wonder whether I deserve all your praises. I am just an ordinary teacher. But I have one aim-that my students should understand whatever I teach. I adopt different ways and means to teachmy concepts and competencies in teaching.
Yes I remember the day you gave me a call after so many years and I recognised your voice, your name your batch of stutents and for a moment I went back to 1980-81′s. You people coming home to see my daughter etc.
It was nice reading your article and the responses.
Thanks to all of them by names. It is surprising that my sis in Africa and my brother who is in California also read this and shown their gratitude to you and their concern to me.
Thanks a lot to all of you.
Ponnamma.
13 October 2010 at 11:53 pm
Hi, I happened to chance upon this blog while on the internet – what an amazing world we live in and what an amazing world we lived in :) Nirmala Convent / our Teachers / Mysore everything about it all even though its 30 years ago is all so fresh. The little instances of then mean so much, it really is a blessing to have been a part of all that.
Good job Manisha i guess you’ve kinda summed it up really well in this blog. I recently happen to hear from Mrs. Eugene through her son Sandesh, they are in England now and i must say its left me amazed that even though year after year they see so many kids they still remember names of students after all those years. I take this opportunity to thank all those Teachers who patiently / at times not so patiently took time to give us some of those precious moments of our lives.
Sanat Attavar
Chennai, INDIA.
14 July 2011 at 1:32 pm
It’s so heartening to read this..Manisha, thumba khushi aaythu…Maybe after reading this many who come to Karnataka chasing a living would start appreciating and learning kannada as much…Thumba chhannagi bardhidheera
14 July 2011 at 9:20 pm
I just second and repeat Somebody’s words: “To a mind bored and frustrated with corruption, crime and nonsense all around, such articles are a great solace, inspiration and rejuvenation.”