The fault lies not in the players but the umpire?

What Karnataka’s selfless politicians want is easy to guess from their sponsored trips to luxury spas in various seaside locations.

But what do Karnataka’s people want from their politicians?


Saritha Rai in the Indian Express:

“What Karnataka yearns for is a transparent, incorruptible chief minister like Bihar’s Nitish Kumar, says Shashank N.D., the founder of Practo, which builds online software for doctors. Bangalore envying Bihar? Who would have even imagined that a few years ago, he asks.

“Event manager Ajith Rao says he envies Gujarat for Narendra Modi, its chief minister. Modi tops the list of India’s most dynamic chief ministers, assertive and capable, says Rao. In contrast, many find Yediyurappa a weak ruler, constantly bogged down by his inability to manage his legislators, his ministers and his partymen.

“Yediyurappa lives dangerously, crying during TV interviews and hurling allegations of voodoo against his rivals. He comes across as feeble and ineffectual. Contrast Karnataka’s leadership with New Delhi’s Sheila Dikshit who appears to be a strong administrator and a vocal politician, says media consultant Usha Radhakrishnan. “

Read the full article: The nine lives of B.S. Yediyurappa

File photograph: Chief minister B.S. Yediyurappa inaugurating a cricket tournament in Mysore in April (Karnataka Photo News)

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

12 Responses to “The fault lies not in the players but the umpire?”

  1. Objectivist Mantra Says:

    I would like to humbly tell Ms. Saritha Rai of Indian Express that “a transparent, incorruptible chief minister” is NOT possible under our socialist system.

    Socialism brings absolute power to the ruling elite, and as we all know “absolute power corrupts absolutely.”

    So lets stop whining about individuals, lets focus on the bigger issue, the route cause of our corruption. Let us talk about reforming this socialism. Lets talk about taking away all economic and discretionary powers from our elected representatives.

    Corrupt politicians are like weeds in a wheat field. if a farmer resorts to plucking out each and every weed from his field, then he will take forever to clean up his land. So the smart way is to spread a kind of fertilizer that makes it impossible for weeds to grow.

    The fertilizer is economic reform.

  2. Gaampa Says:

    Objectivist Mantra – Route Cause???

  3. Objectivist Mantra Says:

    @ Gaampa, Oh, I am sorry, it should be “root cause.” That was a typo.

  4. the colonel Says:

    VOTE: none of the above

  5. Gaby Says:

    Route cause too would make sense if we considered the path – socialism , licence raj, babudom, which has brought us to the current juncture.

  6. Faldo Says:

    @Objectivist mantra – Well said. We need to first recognize that corruption has become a systemic issue and not just an ethical issue. To fix that we need to fix the loopholes in the system. The presence of corruption is closely linked to the living conditions as well as accessibility to resources. We cannot simply expect first world ethics with third world conditions.
    There was another post lamenting the demise of the left parties. We have umpteen number of parties that have taken up the cause of leftists even if they pay lip sympathy to those. I would rather be worried about the absence of a genuine right of center party that can influence public thinking and bring genuine reform.
    Gaby – I agree we need a root cause identification as well as a route change.

  7. Vinay Says:

    It gives me immense pleasure to see more and more people on churumuri realizing the evil that is socialism and regressive leftist thinking, and recognizing that it lies at the root of all problems in India! May the realization spread far and wide!

  8. one eyed jack Says:

    Yearning is one thing voting is another. Only 44 percent of Bangalore voted in the 2008 assembly polls. It is the voters who decided the fate of Yeddyurappa and Karnataka – warts and all. We the people are yet to fathom what it means to be a sovereign socialist secular democratic republic. Thankfully the darling of the urban masses S M Krishna is not being touted as a great leader.

  9. Simple Says:

    The problem is people here see things in black and white. All of leftist thinking is not regressive. All of capitalist thinking is not progressive.

    Left has to shed its dogmatic approach so should the capitalists.

    Thanks to capitalism, we had to witness recession in USA. It was the government which bailed out the economy.

  10. Abhi Says:

    or perhaps the spectators?

  11. Vinay Says:


    The kind of “socialism” that has been practiced in India during the 1950s-1990s deserves to be ground underfoot – try as I might, I cannot see any good having come out of it.

  12. richardw Says:

    @One Eyed Jack –

    “Thankfully the darling of the urban masses S M Krishna is not being touted as a great leader.”

    Hmm… Compared to H D Devegowda, JH Patel, Dharam Singh, HD kumaraswamy, and yes.. BS Yeddurappa… SMK may not be a “great leader”.. but certainly, “best of the lot” where lot tends to worst… :D

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: