What should we do to this Japanese immigrant?

K. JAVEED NAYEEM writes: There is an ongoing tussle between the forest department of Karnataka and wildlife enthusiasts on one side and the breeders, sellers and users on the other side over which side of the conservation fence the Japanese Quail stands.

While the former group says that this bird is protected under the Wildlife Act, the latter argue that it is not at all a native species, having been imported into the country and being bred purely as a table bird.

It is now becoming quite popular as a tasty treat in most restaurants across the country, thanks to the promotion of its breeding on a commercial scale in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Tamil Nadu. It all started a few years ago when quail breeding was promoted in Kerala with the krishi vigyan kendra, Kannur, under the Kerala agricultural University, encouraging it as a part of its creative extension scheme.

The Japanese quail, Coturnix japonica, also known as coturnix quail or Pharaoh’s Quail, is a species of old world quail found in East Asia.

They are a migratory species, breeding in Manchuria, Southeastern Siberia, Northern Japan, and the Korean Peninsula, and wintering in the south of Japan and southern China. They dwell in grasslands and cultivated fields and the species is very abundant across most of its range.

Currently, it is being bred as a table bird in many European and South East Asian countries and also in the US.

The species, which is being reared for its meat and eggs, is seen as a good “dual-purpose bird”. Very interestingly, Japanese quail eggs have orbited the earth in several Soviet and Russian spacecraft, including the Bion 5 satellite and the Salyut 6 and Mir space stations to test the viability of birds’ eggs in space conditions.

In March 1990, quail eggs on Mir were successfully incubated and hatched.

The present controversy in our country stems from the fact that many agencies both government and private, are of the mistaken impression that this bird is the same as the Indian Partridge, which is commonly called ‘Teetar‘ and which is protected under schedule IV of the Indian Wildlife Act (1972).

A few self-educated experts have also quoted Salim Ali, the famous ornithologist while claiming that the Japanese Quail is a wild Indian bird.

But this is not true as the wild Indian Partridge, which this bird resembles quite closely, is the Grey Francolin (formerly also called the Grey Partridge), Francolinus pondicerianus, a larger-sized species found in the plains and drier parts of South Asia.

They are found in open cultivated lands as well as scrub forest and their local name of teetar is based on their calls, a loud and repeated Ka-tee-tar…tee-tar, which is produced by one or more birds. The term Teetar can also refer to many other partridges and quails of varying sizes found in the wild. But each one of them is of a sub- species distinctly different from the Japanese Quail.

Incidentally they all run very swiftly and gracefully and they actually seem to glide rather than run, and folklore says that the native Indian lover can pay no higher compliment to his mistress than to liken her gait to that of the Partridge! This is an observation about which too there is a small controversy because it is attributed to both A. O. Hume and John Lockwood Kipling, father of Rudyard Kipling.

In poetry, too, the partridge is associated with the moon, and, like the lotus, it is supposed to be perpetually longing for it, while one member of the group, the Chakore is even said to eat fire.

Now my interest in this whole dispute about whether it is legal or not to eat this farm-raised bird is not because I relish it but because in our confusion, we may be endangering many of our forest dwelling species.

I know of many instances where many trucks transporting these birds from farms in Kerala and Tamil Nadu to marketing outlets in Karnataka have been intercepted by our officials and the birds simply released into the forests, citing the Wildlife Act.

Now, while this may look like a very merciful and wildlife friendly act to many, it is in fact a very thoughtless and dangerous thing to do. The farm bred birds are capable of harbouring and transmitting some very deadly viral diseases to our wild species which can quickly wipe them out for good.

In a similar scenario in the sixties, the Rinderpest or Cattle Plague infection that was picked up from domestic cattle grazing in and around Bandipur almost wiped out the entire Bison population there which did not have any native immunity against it.

It took a full three decades for the Bison to make a comeback there.

Such an ecological disaster should not be allowed to occur while we stand and argue to decide on which side of the Indian Wildlife Act the Japanese immigrant should stand.

(K. Javed Nayeem is a practising physician who writes a weekly column in Star of Mysore, where a longer version of this piece originally appeared)

Tags: , , , , , ,

9 Responses to “What should we do to this Japanese immigrant?”

  1. vaidya Says:

    Given our past mismanagements and having to deal with attacks of Avian flu almost every other year, do we really want to introduce a foreign species into the mixture? There are far too many such ‘for breeding’ etc cases which have gone horribly wrong. Maybe it’s time we stopped playing with our fragile eco-systems in the interests of ‘development’.
    Look at the story of emus in TN for another angle!

  2. kiran jettimane Says:

    Allow all immigrant birds and mammals in Karnataka.!!
    But put restriction on human immigrants to live here or to get a job!!



  4. Sunita Banerji Says:

    Interesting article on this Japanese immigrant but the last time an airborne immigrant landed up in the hands of India’s farmers and businessmen hoping to make a quick buck it all ended up in one big scam and with a lot of Emu eggs on the face of the investors! This appreciation for this Japanese bird brings a feeling of deja vu to me especially in light of the Australian emu scam which still lingers in public memory. Surprisingly the enthusiasm for the emu also began from Karnataka state and it seems to be that there are a bunch of scamsters out there who latch on to a bird scheme and end up emptying a lot of bird-brained people in India of their investments. Honestly I would be wary of any investments in birds at this moment.

  5. babuds Says:

    Allow the birds to feed from Bangalore’s famous garbage mounds, so that they get infected with avian flue. Cull them and serve them in all the fine-dining restaurants. Two many birds at one shot!:))

  6. Doddi Buddi Says:

    Excellent article by Dr. Nayeem. I hope the authorities will be smart enough to let these birds be eaten in peace by avian gourmets!


    you SURE ARE ….DAMN ANGRY,,,,,,TRY IAC….

  8. Nastika Says:

    Nobody eats a flu-infected chicken. Hence they are culled & disposed. You are living a vegan’s fantasy. May be its good plan to shave off your canine tooth.


  9. preet uberoi Says:

    can any one guide me on the breeding procedures for quails and partridges?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: