Why have Doctors stopped making house-visits?

K. JAVEED NAYEEM writes: Most of the books that recount the experiences of medical practitioners from a bygone era, which I re-read from time to time, invariably tell us about their very interesting house -visit experiences.

A.J. Cronin’s autobiographical masterpiece Adventures in Two Worlds and his novel The Citadel are two very notable examples while James Herriot’s four omnibus editions are in no way inferior or far behind, although they deal with a vet’s adventures with animals and their very interesting owners.

In yester years, almost every movie would have a scene where a doctor, clutching his signature black bag, would make a house visit to see a patient. Interestingly, on his way out the bag would invariably be carried, by the patient’s son or other relative who would see the doctor off!

The mortifying diagnosis that the doctor would announce almost in a whisper would be TB, which then had no cure. And when a cure for TB finally did come somewhere in the early 1960s the diagnosis promptly changed to cancer, to heighten the impact of the patient’s helplessness.

Another thing that intrigued and amused me then was why while a doctor was shown making a house call even to see a mildly sick patient, almost no movie ever showed a patient being taken to see a doctor in his consulting room as is the practice now.

***

While making house calls was almost standard practice for most doctors in the past, these days house-visits by doctors are almost unheard of and now even in a serious emergency it is almost impossible to get a doctor to come home and see a patient.

Very often when death comes calling at home and the relatives are not able to say with certainty whether the person is dead or only deeply unconscious it helps if a doctor sees him or her to dispel any lingering doubts. But to get a doctor to make a house visit even to do this is not very easy and anxious relatives have no other option but to shift the person to a hospital only to be told there that he or she is beyond any help.

It is also not very easy for elderly persons who stay alone without their siblings or other relatives to seek and get medical help in an emergency. These days this situation has become commonplace, with children working far away from home being unable to attend to the medical needs of their elderly parents on a day to day basis.

And most elderly people have some medical problem or the other which needs periodic attention.

Even for those aged people who have their relatives with them it is not very easy to go over to a hospital if they happen to be very infirm or bedridden especially if they live in an apartment block where a stretcher trolley cannot be accommodated in the elevator.

Considering all these difficulties it will certainly be a very great boon to society if some doctors are available who would be willing to make house calls in an emergency.

Very often I have told many doctors who have not been doing very well in their practices that they can certainly improve their standing by agreeing to make house calls and I have found that those who followed this advice seriously quickly became very successful. But the sad part is that once they become well known and patients start coming to their clinics they invariably stop going to patients’ homes in times of need.

There is indeed a very great demand for house calls in our society and doctors would do well to include this service in their daily practice.

***

Some years ago I met a very successful doctor in Bangalore who is doing very well financially without any postgraduate qualifications. Very surprisingly he has no clinic. He only makes house calls every day and is busy from morning till evening six days a week.

He has a very organised approach and he registers all his calls in a diary and at the beginning of each day he prioritizes them according to the seriousness of his patients and the traffic conditions so that he does not waste time in traffic jams.

Every patient’s number is called back and recorded for safety’s sake and it is also messaged to another mobile phone at home. His driver doubles as his secretary, maintaining his diary and holding on to it at all times. He never accompanies his master into the patient’s house and he never leaves the car during the calls to preclude any compromise to their safety.

This doctor has become so popular that he gets regular referrals from consultants who can keep a better watch on their patients’ progress through him. He has now narrowed down his area of operation to what he can manage best and he told me that there is certainly much scope for many more players if they can co-ordinate their operations.

I hope this trend picks up and helps in getting medical care to bedridden patients’ bedsides in the comfort and convenience of their homes, saving them the bother of going to hospitals for every tiny problem. Thankfully this kind of medical care seems all set to make a beginning in our own city too.

A very close friend of mine and a fellow-physician with very good qualifications and a good deal of experience too called me up recently to tell me that he has seriously thought of starting this kind of practice as an act of public service. I was overjoyed and wished him well as I knew that he would indeed be doing some much needed good to ailing humanity.

I hope he does not get disillusioned by any initial teething troubles that are bound to be there and more importantly I also hope that other members of our fraternity see the sense in what he is embarking on and encourage him. Three cheers to the man who has decided to step out of the box to put some good cheer into the lives of those who need it most!

(K. Javeed Nayeem is a practising physician who writes a weekly column for Star of Mysore, where this piece originally appeared)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

9 Responses to “Why have Doctors stopped making house-visits?”

  1. the colonel Says:

    thank you doctor.

    may your tribe increase

  2. K.Balasubrahmanyan Says:

    excellent eye opener to me.

  3. ramanath MAIYA Says:

    Dr. Javeedji,

    This is the requirement for today’s senior citizens particularly in urban areas clustered with high density traffic. These thoughts and execution in the current times, make life much more simpler and enjoyable. Great Deed Doctorji!!! Thanks would be a small word for this noble deed. My salutations once again to all these dedicated Godly creatures.

  4. Ajith Says:

    I hope India sees more doctors like Javed Nayeem and his close friend and the gentleman from Bangalore and less like Pravin Togadia, Maya Kodnani etc. Having said that, the practice of home visits is still prevalent in many other countries e.g. Sri Lanka, UK, Australia etc. I was recently supervising some GPs in Sudan and Kenya on a WHO telemedicine project and was surprised at the number of home visits they were doing every week.

  5. Jayashree/Ramaprasad Says:

    I am reminded of Dr Krisnaswamyrao LMP in KM Puram Mysore.
    he used to do house calls between 7am to 9am, 2pm to 5pm and 9pm to 10pm. He used to go about on his Raleigh bicycle, with a Doctors bag in the carrier. In an emergency 24×7, a Great friend he used to be. His visit charges would be affection, a cup of coffee and Rs2/-..

  6. Amit M Says:

    While it certainly is a wonderful sentiment, I wonder if any of the people leaving comments here would agree to visit multiple houses throughout the day, every day, in insane traffic such as Bangalore’s in exchange for a low fee, as a part of their jobs?

    Honestly?

  7. harkol Says:

    The trouble with the medical education is that it costs way too much today, produces only 30,000 MBBS doctors a year for a population that is almost 3 times of the times gone by.

    That makes it impossible for doctors to spare time in travel to visit patients, instead they want patients to waste their time visiting them.

    THe only way to remedy the situation is to have qualified medical practitioners that have perhaps 3yr graduation. They can take care of moderate ailments and suggest higher treatments only when necessary.

    Such practitioners should be able to earn a decent living, and should be churned out at about couple of lakhs a year from our colleges. This will bridge a critical need.

  8. vishesh sharma Says:

    Thanks for sharing such an interesting post. Sometimes in the interest of absolute equality, we forget that there are those who will be unable to receive our help if we do not go the extra mile for them. The elderly deserve special attention, more than most. Having spent their entire lives helping build a world for us, we could at least support them to live in dignity and make these the golden years of their life.

  9. Divakar Says:

    It certainly is a great idea, which immensely benefits all bed-ridden patients. But unfortunately, the days are gone when doctors were revered as Gods, – especially in the present-day crime city of Bangalore.

    Can anybody guarantee the safety of such doctors from – 1)disgruntled doctor-bashing relatives of patients who only view doctors as failed vendors whenever an unfortunate death happens? 2) from relatives who refuse to pay the fees later or pay only a pittance? 3) from thieves who way-lay during nights? 4)from greedy traffic cops, whenever a two-wheeler bound doctor forgets helmet out of haste?

    Anybody?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: